Press on nails vs acrylic nails damage comparison guide - TsukiNails

The Damage Report: Do Press-On Nails Ruin Your Natural Nails Like Acrylics?

We all know the feeling. You sit in the salon chair, soaking your fingers in acetone for 20 minutes, only to have the technician bring out the electric drill. You wince as they file down your natural nail plate to make the acrylic stick.
When you finally take them off weeks later, your nails are paper-thin, sensitive, and peeling.
Is this just the price of beauty? In 2026, the answer is no.
Let’s look at the science of damage between Traditional Acrylics and TsukiNails Handmade Press-Ons.

1. The "Roughing Up" Myth

  • Acrylics/Dip: To make heavy acrylic adhere, technicians must aggressively file the surface of your natural nail to create "texture." This thins your nail plate over time, leading to weakness and breakage.

  • Press-Ons: You only need to lightly buff the shine away (not the nail structure) to make them stick.

  • The Verdict: Press-ons require 90% less filing, preserving your nail thickness.

2. The Removal Process (The Danger Zone)
Most damage happens during removal, not application.

  • Acrylics: Requires soaking in harsh 100% Acetone for 30+ minutes, which dehydrates your skin and nails, making them brittle. Or worse—prying them off, which rips layers of keratin from your nail bed.

  • Press-Ons:

    • With Glue: Soaked off in warm soapy water and oil (gentle).

    • With Tabs: Peels off like a sticker with zero chemicals.

  • The Verdict: TsukiNails removal is essentially chemical-free and drill-free.

Comparison of damaged nails from acrylics vs healthy nails from press ons - TsukiNails

3. The "Breathing" Room

  • Acrylics: Often worn back-to-back for months (or years) without a break. Moisture can get trapped deep underneath, leading to serious fungal infections if not maintained perfectly.

  • Press-Ons: Because they are easy to pop off, many users take them off for a day or two between sets. This allows you to oil your natural nails and monitor their health regularly.

4. Can Press-Ons Cause Damage?
Honesty time: Yes, IF you rip them off.
The only way a press-on nail damages you is if you force it off while the glue is still hard.

  • The Fix: Patience. Use our "Soak & Oil" method, and your natural nails will emerge untouched.

Healthy nail care routine using cuticle oil - TsukiNails

Conclusion
You don't have to sacrifice your nail health for length. By switching to handmade press-ons, you break the cycle of "damage and cover-up," allowing your natural nails to grow strong while still looking fabulous.

[Button: Switch to Healthy Nails]

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.